Cropping

Mixtures rock! Next level resistance testing tells a big story

Peter Newman, AHRI, August 20, 2021

THIS Australian Herbicide Resistance Initiative (AHRI) Insight has a bit of a twist. Peter Newman has composed and performed a rap. You can check out the video above and follow the lyrics here:

 Alright stop, collaborate and listen

Busi’s back with a brand new invention

Something grabbed a hold of him tightly

Testing resistance daily and nightly

Will he ever stop, I don’t know

Turn off the lights and he’ll glow

Testing was a problem, Busi has solved it

Check AHRI insight while my DJ revolves it.

Test, test baby!

Robert Busi

AHRI researcher, Roberto Busi, has just completed a mammoth herbicide resistance testing task:

  • 579 ryegrass samples
  • From 298 farms
  • Across 4 states of Australia
  • 21 herbicides tested – 12 standalones and 9 two-way mixtures.
  • Over 15,000 individual resistance tests.
  • 2 million ryegrass seeds.

And the results? There are lots, which we have summarised into ten key findings from this research.

In a nutshell:

South Australia and Victoria are epicentres of resistance to Sakura® (pyroxasulfone), Prosulfocarb and trifluralin.

NSW has the highest levels of resistance to glyphosate.

All states have significant clethodim resistance with Western Australia leading the pack.

 

And possibly the most significant results of all – Herbicide Mixtures Rock!

The resistance frequency to stand-alone pre-emergence herbicides ranged from 10% to 34%, yet resistance to herbicide mixtures ranged from 0% to 6%.

 

Such a large study produces a lot of data that is too great to summarise in a few dot points so we have distilled it down to 10 key messages.

 

  1. Sakura and Prosulfocarb are in trouble

We have a big problem looming with Sakura, Trifluralin and Prosulfocarb resistance, especially in New South Wales (NSW) and South Australia (SA).  We’ve known about trifluralin resistance for a long time, but these levels of Sakura and prosulfocarb resistance are concerning.

 

  1. Mixtures Rock!

We’ve said it before and we’ll say it again, herbicide mixtures are exceeding our expectations and have a big part to play in managing resistant weeds.  There is no better example than checking out the Trifluralin + Sakura mix in NSW and Victoria below compared to these herbicides stand alone. Luximax + Triallate was the winner in the mixtures competition.

 

  1. Luximax did well

“Of course it did well”, you might be thinking, “it’s a brand new herbicide”! Yes, Luximax is new, but there is a risk with any new herbicide that there may be existing cross resistance from all of the herbicides we have used in the past. We previously reported that “Luximax gets it’s own box” here https://ahri.uwa.edu.au/luximax-gets-its-own-new-box/ and this research is further confirmation.

 

  1. Propyzamide also did well

Still very little or no resistance to this herbicide in Australia at this stage which is both pleasing and remarkable.

 

  1. What is going on in NSW? Zero pre-em resistance!

There were only 25 populations tested from NSW, all from the low rainfall, western districts. The agronomists taking these samples find that their area does have low levels of resistance to pre-emergence herbicides but they weren’t expecting it to be quite this low.

 

Table 1: Resistant ryegrass (% of populations) to pre-emergent herbicide treatments (developing resistance + resistant) across NSW, SA, VIC & WA.

Note * Luximax + Trifluralin tested in summer and stand alone Luximax tested in winter creating a very small difference.

 

  1. Everyone has a Clethodim resistance problem

Sure, WA is leading the pack here, but every state has significant clethodim resistance.

 

  1. Mixtures rock! – part 2

Clethodim + Butroxydim is much better than clethodim alone in all states. It’s not the complete answer, and there’s a growing number of populations with resistance to this mix, but it’s a great mix.

 

Table 2: Resistant ryegrass (% of populations) to ‘Dim’ herbicide treatments (developing resistance + resistant) across NSW, SA, VIC & WA.

  1. NSW is leading the country when it comes to glyphosate resistance

This is likely due to all 25 NSW samples coming from the low rainfall area where chemical fallow has been a significant part of the rotation. The agronomists who took these samples were alarmed, but not surprised.

 

  1. Paraquat still works

Hooray, some good news! No paraquat resistance was discovered in this research, however, we do know that paraquat resistant ryegrass exists and several populations were confirmed resistant in 2021. We also know that many growers have switched to double paraquat knockdowns (paraquat followed by paraquat) in NSW and Vic with great success. We need to develop strategies to look after paraquat with this practice. A good start is to ensure that we mix a group 14 (G) herbicide plus a pre-emergent herbicide with the second paraquat.

 

Table 3: Resistant ryegrass (% of populations) to knockdown herbicide treatments (developing resistance + resistant) across NSW, SA, VIC & WA.

  1. Testing 21 herbicides and mixtures is next level herbicide resistance testing. We are very proud of what Roberto has achieved here with this testing service and research. We believe that this is the start of a new level of herbicide resistance testing that should be embraced by every Australian farmer, and should set the standard for the rest of the world.

 

Methods

579 ryegrass populations were collected from 298 farms at the end of the 2019 growing season: NSW (25), SA (98), VIC (104) and WA (352). Fields were chosen according to the grower or consultant’s interests so it is important to point out that this is not a random survey. Seed samples were screened in February to March, 2020 as part of the summer-autumn season in a cooled glasshouse (25oC average temperature).  The herbicides Luximax®, Sakura®, prosulfocarb, trifluralin, glyphosate and paraquat were tested in winter with the rationale of assessing herbicide efficacy at a lower temperature (16oC average recorded during the winter study)

Source: AHRI

Acknowledgements; ‘Herbicide resistance across the Australian continent’ Roberto Busi, Hugh J. Beckie, Andy Bates, Tim Boyes, Chris Davey, Barry Haskins, Simon Mock, Peter Newman, Aimone Porri and Andrea Onofri.

 

 

 

HAVE YOUR SAY

Your email address will not be published.

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.

Comments

Get Grain Central's news headlines emailed to you -
FREE!