Lack of allocation transparency a concern: ACCC study

Grain Central, September 8, 2022
Two vessels, one carrying wheat and the other barley, loaded at Viterra's Port Lincoln terminal in the 2021 Christmas week.

Viterra, along with GrainCorp and CBH Group, are Australia’s biggest operators of bulk grain port terminals. Photo: Viterra

GRAIN exporters are concerned about a lack of transparency in the way port operators allocate capacity to them, according to a report published today by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).

Entitled Bulk grain ports monitoring report – industry update, the report summarises the views of Australia’s bulk grain exporters in the wake of the record 2020-21 shipping year.

In its consultation with the bulk grain export industry for the report, ACCC has shown that grower representative groups and some exporters generally support regulation of bulk grain export supply chains, but port terminal operators largely do not.

A key issue the ACCC consulted on was the suitability of the Bulk Wheat Code of Conduct, the regulation that ensures all bulk wheat exporters have fair and transparent access to port terminal services.

“The bulk grain export industry has undergone some significant changes over the last five years, so we need to consider whether the current regulation of exporter access to port terminals is still fit for purpose,” ACCC deputy chair Mick Keogh said.

“In recent years we’ve seen an increase in the number of port terminal service providers, a higher percentage of non-wheat grain bulk exports, and, at some ports, an increased market share of grain shipments by exporters associated with companies that operate the port terminal facilities.”

“While the grains industry has mixed views about the effectiveness of the current code, it’s clear it isn’t working optimally and a review is needed.

“The ACCC is especially mindful of the regulatory burden the code imposes on new port terminals.”

Figure 1: Bulk grain shipments by state and commodity.

Next review due

The Federal Government first reviewed the code in 2017, and is required to commence a second review this year.

The ACCC believes that, given developments in the market over the past five years, government and industry would benefit from a detailed review that considers whether the current regulatory approach is fit for purpose, and what changes are needed.

Consistent with the record year for bulk grain exports in 2020-21, port terminal service providers told the ACCC they experienced unprecedented demand for capacity.

“The massive harvest in season 2020-21 resulted in the largest ever volume of bulk grain exports, so it was a good test of both port capacity and the impact of reduced regulation in these markets over the last few years.”

Several exporters raised concerns about access to port terminal facilities in 2020–21, and some of the smaller exporters said capacity constraints at established port facilities forced them to seek access at new ones or rely on mobile ship loaders.

However, some exporters say that mobile-loader operations are not perfect substitutes for fixed-loader operations, and they questioned their value outside of high-demand years when capacity at larger facilities is constrained.

The report released today complements the December 2021 Bulk grain ports monitoring report – data update which provided data on bulk grain exports.

Source: ACCC


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your comment will not appear until it has been moderated.
Contributions that contravene our Comments Policy will not be published.


Get Grain Central's news headlines emailed to you -